A grave transmission error

 Just a year before Berlin replaced Bonn as the German capital, I was there for a conference. My cabbie looked around, glanced at me and asked: Do you know the national bird of Germany? No! I said! Cranes! He replied. Which one? I asked. The Construction cranes, he retorted. I looked around. Sure enough, all I could see around were nothing but construction cranes. So overwhelmingly did they dominate the skyline! doweshowbellyad=0; Have you noticed the unmistakable change in the Indian urban skyline of late? Just stand atop a building in any urban part of India to know the difference. Up to seven service providers, all vying with one another to hog the skyline with their towers on which is mounted their transmitters to satiate the nation’s long suppressed need for telecommunications. Also Read RCoVL to merge 9 arms with itself FII investments in Bharti Airtel hit a block But it is one thing to feel great about this changing landscape, completely different if you look at the critical attendant issues. I am referring to the health hazard. Talk about the perils of using mobile phones has been around for years, with no conclusive evidence really. Often a claim is made that using mobile handsets is dangerous, and that it causes brain tumour, to be quickly debunked by a study saying how it is harmless for humans. It’s a different matter that these debunking theories, as claimed by some, are always at the behest of interested mobile companies. The threat of hazard posed by the towers, or at least its realisation, is of a more recent origin. But a Delhi-based NGO was alarmed adequately enough to move a PIL in the Supreme Court against their mushrooming growth and the attendant health risks. The court too, on its part, thought the matter was serious enough for it to seek responses from a bevy of government ministries. India can take a lead in the issue of mobile phones as a health hazard. What stops us from setting up a body of experts drawn from say the All India Institute of Medical Sciences and IISc to go into the technical-medical issues involved? Whatever might be the truth, the fact is that there is enough data to show that it is better to be cautious. In Australia, for example, as recently as May this year, a spate of brain tumours among staff forced a university to close part of its business school and test for radiation emissions from rooftop phone towers. The university discovered with shock that five of its employees had tested positive for brain tumour in the past month alone, in addition to two others in 1999 and 2001. Two were malignant and five were benign. While the university’s decision was greeted with shock by the business school employees, electrical workers who worked near the mobile phone towers were barred from working for fears of links between emissions and a “caner cluster”. The mobile industry, as expected, reacted that there was nothing to prove that the tumours were in any way linked to emissions from the mobile towers. Fair enough! There is nothing conclusive yet. But is it still not something that needs to be looked into?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How about inter-connect exchanges?

 In the late ’80s, when Sam Pitroda controlled the reins of Indian telecom, there was constant talk of a new telecom policy. But once V P Singh came to power in early ’90s, Sam fell out of favour and the nation blundered along without a cogent policy. A few years down the line, the irrepressible N Vittal assumed charge of the Telecom Commission, becoming the first IAS officer to assume that role, and kept assuring all that the policy’d be out any day now, till one day, out of sheer exasperation, he told me, “I think I will just say that the new policy is coming on this day, this month, and not add the year to it”. We have come a long way since then. From a tele-density of under 1, it is now nudging 10, and mobiles have outstripped landlines in number. And sure enough, since the exciting Vittal quote, we are now readying the third policy document, whose draft has been around for a while. Like all documents, this one too is being analysed threadbare by intere...
Read more

War over spectrum allocation

 upset with the way the department of telecommunications has allocated spectrum for mobile operators. In a missive to the Telecom Commission chairman, and then to the prime minister, he has ripped through the department’s move to link spectrum allocation with technology and subscriber base. Gauging the seriousness of Tata’s allegations, and the fact that it has the potential to derail their ambitions, the GSM operators too have gone into an overdrive, with their association and the individual operators all sending rejoinders to whoever cares to listen. A spectrum war has begun. As the subscriber base has grown, the operators have been unable to meet the service quality, so they claim, due to the inadequate spectrum. However, since most of the spectrum in this country is held by defence forces, it is impossible for the government to make it available to operators at one go, as is done internationally. So the government allots additional spectrum “based on a...
Read more

The illusion of spectrum scarcity

 Come what come may, penned the Bard, Time and the hour runs through the roughest day. Actually, time brings all things to pass! Everything is a matter of chronology, really. Consider, for instance, the radio frequency spectrum for mobile telephony. In particular, the issue of extra bandwidth for the next — the third—generation (3G) mobile services. With the passage of time and technological change, the notion of routinely licensing chunks of spectrum for service providers is now being vigorously questioned, the world over. Very unlike in the analogue era, today’s digital technologies do allow for new approaches to freeing up and managing spectrum. As much as 99% of even highly saturated bands may be vacant in any specific moment in time and space, innovative software can dynamically shift signals to make full use of the fleeting openings in the wireless “ether”(“white spaces”). The point is, new technologies do allow for much flexibility in spectrum usage. The ...
Read more